Reds vs Mets Free Picks & Tips | Power Hitting Clash at Pitcher-Friendly Citi Field

Reds vs Mets Free Picks & Tips | Power Hitting Clash at Pitcher-Friendly Citi Field

Game Details

Cincinnati Reds (51-47, 5-5 in last 10) vs. New York Mets (55-43, 5-5 in last 10)

Date/Time: July 19, 2025 — 4:10 PM ET

Location: Citi Field, New York, NY

TV: MLB Network, SNY, FDSOH

Betting Odds

Point Spread: Reds +1.5 (-140) / Mets −1.5 (+116)

Moneyline: Reds +150 / Mets -178

Over/Under Total: 8.5 runs

Money is flowing toward the over despite Citi Field's pitcher-friendly reputation.

Game Overview

The Cincinnati Reds arrive at Citi Field with newfound momentum, having won five of their last six games including yesterday's 8-4 victory over these same Mets. Cincinnati's offense exploded for four home runs Friday night, continuing a trend where they've hit multiple homers in four of their last seven games. The Mets, meanwhile, have struggled with consistency at the plate, relying heavily on Juan Soto (who homered again Friday) while Francisco Lindor endures a cold stretch (.225 average since June 1). Despite their recent loss, the Mets remain formidable at home with a 33-15 record, creating an intriguing matchup between their home-field advantage and Cincinnati's surging offense.

Key Matchups & Analysis

  • Starting Pitching Contrast
    Clay Holmes (8-4, 3.31 ERA) gives the Mets a significant edge over Nick Martinez (7-9, 4.78 ERA). Holmes has been a pleasant surprise as a converted reliever who's thrived in the rotation, holding opponents to a .234 batting average. Martinez has struggled with consistency, particularly against left-handed hitters who are batting .276 against him this season.
  • Cincinnati's Resurgent Power
    The Reds' power display on Friday with four home runs is notable because Citi Field traditionally suppresses offense (0.913 runs factor, 24th in MLB). Austin Hays is on fire with 3 homers in his last 10 games, while Matt McLain showed signs of breaking out of his season-long slump with a homer last night.
  • Bullpen Factors
    The Mets' bullpen took a beating Friday night, having to cover five innings after Sean Manaea's limited pitch count. This creates an advantage for Cincinnati, especially with Emilio Pagán (20 saves) well-rested. The Mets did get a boost with Brooks Raley's return from Tommy John surgery yesterday, but they'll be without Max Kranick, who is headed for season-ending surgery.
  • Run Line Implications
    The Reds are 48-44 ATS this season while the Mets are slightly underwater at 46-47. In Holmes' starts, the Mets are just 8-9 ATS despite his strong ERA, indicating they often win his starts by narrow margins. The +1.5 run line for Cincinnati offers value given their recent offensive output.

Prediction

I’m backing the OVER 8.5 runs (-118) as my top play today. While Citi Field typically suppresses scoring, several factors point toward a higher-scoring affair. First, Cincinnati’s offense is clicking after their four-homer outburst Friday night. Second, Martinez’s 4.78 ERA provides plenty of scoring opportunities for the Mets. Third, the Mets bullpen had to cover five innings yesterday and could be vulnerable in the later frames. Finally, the betting market has pushed this total up despite Citi Field’s reputation, indicating sharp money believes in the over.

For a side play, I lean toward Cincinnati +1.5 (-140). While Holmes gives the Mets an edge in starting pitching, the Reds’ bats are heating up at the right time, and they’ve already demonstrated they can hit at Citi Field. The Mets are just 8-9 ATS in Holmes’ starts, suggesting they don’t blow teams out when he’s on the mound. With TJ Friedl taking one for the team (literally, three times yesterday), this Reds squad is showing the determination needed to keep games close.

Best Bets

Betting Pick: Take the Over 8.5 runs (-118)
Final Score Prediction: Mets 5, Reds 4

Handicapping Tools

SAVE BIG MONEY BY BETTING AT -105 REDUCED ODDS!
Quit wasting your hard earned money! Make the switch from -110 to -105 odds today
You'll be so glad that you did! Click Here!