Blue Jays vs Pirates Free Picks & Tips | Scherzer Seeks 220th Win Against Struggling Keller

Blue Jays vs Pirates Free Picks & Tips | Scherzer Seeks 220th Win Against Struggling Keller

Game Details

Blue Jays vs Pirates Free Picks & Tips | Scherzer Seeks 220th Win Against Struggling Keller

Date/Time: August 19, 2025 — 6:40 PM ET

Location: PNC Park, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

TV: Fox Sports

Betting Odds

Point Spread: Blue Jays -1.5 (+115) / Pirates +1.5 (-135)

Moneyline: Blue Jays -150 / Pirates +126

Over/Under Total: 8.0 runs

Early action has shown support for the over, pushing the juice to -120 despite Toronto's slugger Guerrero dealing with a hamstring issue.

Game Overview

The Blue Jays suffered a 5-2 loss in the series opener Monday after Vladimir Guerrero Jr. exited with hamstring tightness, but they'll look to bounce back with Max Scherzer seeking his 220th career win. Toronto is still leading the AL East by a comfortable margin despite going 5-5 in their last 10, while Pittsburgh has struggled mightily with a 3-7 mark in their last 10 games. The Pirates capitalized on several Blue Jays errors in Monday's contest, but their offense has been anemic, hitting just .215 during this recent 10-game stretch.

Key Matchups & Analysis

  • Pitching Matchup: Max Scherzer vs. Mitch Keller
    Max Scherzer (3-2, 3.83 ERA) continues his comeback season with impressive metrics, sporting a 1.07 WHIP and 52 strikeouts across 54 innings. Mitch Keller (5-11, 4.13 ERA) has better numbers than his record indicates, but has received terrible run support all season, evidenced by his 112 strikeouts over 141.2 innings.
  • Blue Jays' Road Struggles
    Toronto is just 31-32 on the road this season, a stark contrast to their home dominance. They'll need to improve their road performance heading into the final stretch of the season, especially with Guerrero potentially missing time.
  • PNC Park Factor
    PNC Park ranks as the 5th most hitter-friendly venue for runs this season with a 1.054 park factor, but has suppressed home runs (0.893 HR factor). This benefits both Scherzer and Keller, who have managed to limit the long ball this season.
  • Bullpen Advantage
    Toronto's bullpen depth gives them a significant edge in this matchup. Jeff Hoffman leads the team with 27 saves, while Brendon Little (24 holds) and Louis Varland (19 holds) provide reliable bridge options. Pittsburgh's thin relief corps features Dennis Santana (8 saves) as their primary closer.

Prediction

I’m backing the Blue Jays on the run line (-1.5, +115) tonight. Scherzer’s experience and pedigree give Toronto a substantial pitching advantage, particularly against a Pirates team that’s been outscored by 32 runs in their last 10 games. While Keller has shown flashes, his 5-11 record isn’t just bad luck – the Pirates struggle to provide run support, and Toronto’s bullpen is significantly stronger should this game remain close into the later innings.

The key factor for me is Scherzer’s motivation to reach 220 career wins and Toronto’s urgency to maintain their division lead. Even with Guerrero potentially sidelined, the Blue Jays lineup remains potent with Davis Schneider heating up (11-for-29 with 3 HRs in his last 10 games). Pittsburgh’s .215 team batting average over their last 10 contests simply won’t generate enough offense against a pitcher of Scherzer’s caliber.

PNC Park does favor hitters more than most realize (1.054 runs factor), but I expect Scherzer to navigate this environment effectively. The value on the run line at plus money is simply too good to pass up against a Pirates team that’s been routinely outclassed in recent weeks.

Best Bets

Betting Pick: Take the jays -1.5 +115
Final Score Prediction: Toronto Blue Jays 5, Pittsburgh Pirates 2

Handicapping Tools

SAVE BIG MONEY BY BETTING AT -105 REDUCED ODDS!
Quit wasting your hard earned money! Make the switch from -110 to -105 odds today
You'll be so glad that you did! Click Here!